- Fixed and fixed indexed annuities cannot lose principal to market movement — that part of the sales pitch is accurate.
- Variable annuities and buffer annuities can lose principal directly, by design.
- Every annuity type can lose money through surrender charges and market value adjustments if you exit early.
- Rider fees can reduce account value in years the contract credits nothing — a slow loss that never appears as one.
- The largest uninsured risk is the carrier itself, which is why ratings and state guaranty limits belong in the purchase decision.
The pitch is usually some version of "you can't lose money." It is not a lie, exactly — it is a true statement about one risk, delivered in a way that implies there are no others. There are six others. Here they all are, with which products they apply to.
1. Market loss — and this is the one the pitch is about
Fixed annuities and MYGAs: no. Your money sits in the insurer's general account and credits a declared rate. Markets are irrelevant to it.
Fixed indexed annuities: no. A negative index year credits 0%. Principal does not decline from index movement, ever.
Buffer annuities and RILAs: yes, by design. Any decline beyond the buffer hits your account value directly. A 10% buffer in a 40% drawdown costs you 30%.
Variable annuities: yes, fully. Subaccounts are investments and they fall like investments.
So when someone says "you can't lose money in an annuity," the honest response is: which annuity? Two of the four major categories can lose principal to markets, and both are actively sold.
2. Surrender charges — every type, no exceptions
Exit during the surrender period and the surrender charge comes off. Schedules commonly run seven to ten years, starting high and declining annually.
This is the most common real-world loss, and it happens to people who bought products that "can't lose money." Surrender in year two of a ten-year schedule and you will receive materially less than you paid. The guarantee was against market movement. It was never against changing your mind.
3. Market value adjustment — the second exit charge
Many fixed and indexed contracts add a market value adjustment on top of the surrender charge, moving your payout up or down based on where interest rates sit relative to your issue date.
Rates up since you bought means a negative adjustment stacked on the surrender charge. Worth knowing: this one can go your way — if rates have fallen, the adjustment is positive and can meaningfully offset the charge. It is the only item on this list that sometimes pays you.
4. Rider fees in flat years
An income rider charges annually whether or not the contract credits anything. In a year the index finishes down, a fixed indexed annuity credits 0% and the rider fee still comes out — so the account value falls.
This is a genuine principal loss on a product marketed as principal-protected, and it is contractual rather than hidden. Two or three flat years with a rider running is a measurable decline. Worse: many riders charge against the benefit base, which grows at a guaranteed roll-up rate, so the fee can increase in exactly the years your actual money did nothing.
5. Inflation
A level payment that covers your expenses at 65 covers noticeably less at 85. A fixed contract crediting 4% in a 3% inflation environment is growing about 1% in purchasing power before tax.
The dollars are guaranteed. What they buy is not, and no annuity guarantee addresses this unless you pay for a cost-of-living rider — which buys rising payments with a smaller first check.
6. Opportunity cost
Not a loss on a statement, but real. Money committed to a ten-year surrender period at a modest credited rate is money that could not do anything else — including take a better rate that appeared in year three, or stay liquid for an opportunity you did not anticipate.
The honest benchmark is not zero. It is the MYGA rate you could have locked or the CD you could have laddered. Beating zero is not the test.
7. Carrier failure — the one nobody prices
Every guarantee on this page depends on one company staying solvent for as long as forty years. Annuities are not FDIC insured. No federal insurance exists.
What does exist: your state guaranty association, which continues covered benefits up to a statutory limit if the insurer fails. That system has worked in every major life insurer insolvency of the past four decades, and the limit is real — above it, you are an unsecured creditor.
Which is why this is a purchase decision rather than a footnote: check the carrier's rating and outlook with a date on it, look up your state's limit, and size the premium under it. Larger amounts split across separately rated carriers get separate limits. Twenty minutes of work against a forty-year promise.
The version of the pitch that would be true
"A fixed or fixed indexed annuity cannot lose principal to market movement. It can lose value to surrender charges if you exit early, to rider fees in flat years, and to inflation over time — and the guarantee depends on this specific insurer, which is rated X as of this month, against a state guaranty limit of Y."
That sentence is longer, entirely accurate, and describes a product that is genuinely useful for the right person. The short version is not a lie. It is just answering a smaller question than the one you asked.
Frequently asked
Want to know what your contract can actually lose?
Send it over. We will tell you which of the seven applies to your specific product, what the exit costs today, and where your premium sits against your state guaranty limit — free, and with nothing for us to sell you.
Book a Free Review →